APRIL 28, 2009 – CONSOLIDATED BOARD OF EQUALIZATION:

Meeting called to order by Chairman Fischbach at 10:00 A.M. in the Commissioner’s Chambers, Courthouse Annex, Brown County, SD. Present were Commissioners Alm, Elliott, Sutton and Levsen. Mary Worlie, Leo Lesher and Gene Loeschke from the Director of Equalization Office were also in attendance.

APPEALS:
Moved by Sutton, seconded by Levsen to approve the following recommendation from the Director of Equalization: 1.Darwin Vetch-Lt 7 Blk 43 Hagerty & Lloyd Addn @ 20,000, maintain equalization. All members present voting aye. Motion carried.

Moved by Sutton, seconded by Levsen to approve the following recommendation from the Director of Equalization: 2.Dana & Becky Randall-Lt 4 Blk 1 Melros 6th Addn @ 204,792, maintain equalization.
3-7.Robert Vanriter-Lt 9 Blk 2 Normal Addn @ 73,980; W 71’ of Lt 5-6 Blk 23 Thomas Addn @ 53,220; E ½ Lt 7 Blk 48 Second Addn @ 27,958, maintain equalization; Lt 10 Blk 1 Normal Addn from 104,583 to 67,703; Lt 3 Blk 40 Thomas Addn from 81,200 to 52,740, adjust after review. 8.Scott & Rhonda Clark-Lt 12 Blk 4 North Plains 2nd Addn from 188,350 to 185,810, adjust after review. 9.Sharon Leisen Watts & Dorothy Leisen Howe-S ½ Lt 5 all Lt 6 Blk 12 North Aberdeen Addn @ 74,575, maintain equalization. 10.Loren Lomis-W 75’ of Lt 7 & W 75’ of S ½ Lt 8 Blk 3 OP to Aberdeen @ 73,727, maintain equalization. 11.Bridgestone/Firestone-Firestone Addn @ 472,265, maintain equalization. 12.Anthony & Patricia Schwan-Lt 5 Boulevards Subd SE 6-123-63 from 440,350 to 421,470, adjust after review. 13.Jensen Rock & Sand Inc-Reeses OL 1 ex H-1 E ½ NE 23-123-64 from 287,505 to 328,439, correct error. 14.Michael & Colleen Fowle-Lt 2 Blk 2 Mehlhoffs 11th Addn @ 290,140, maintain equalization. 15.Donald & Carole VonWald-Lt 6 Blk 8 15th Addn to Highland North from 222,635 to 197,570, adjust after review. 16.Thomas F Agnitsch-Lt 9 Blk 10 Forest Acres 7th Addn from 163,430 to 147,765, adjust after review. 17.Forrest C Allred-#3 Lt 5 BB Wards 1st Subd Lt 1-3 Blk 6 OP from 64,225 to 43,332, adjust after review. 18.Steven Ballinger-S 81.5’ Lt 12 Blk 13 Thomas Addn from 100,918 to 82,723, adjust after review. 19.Steven & Christine Beare-Parker Improvement Addn (Blk 12 3rd Addn to Highland North Addn from 267,670 to 249,080, adjust after review. 20.Thomas & Deanna Blanchard-Lt 4 Blk 2 Northview 3rd Addn from 155,520 to 142,810, adjust after review. 21.Morgan Brockel-Lts 871-872 Morning Heights Subd from 126,400 to 118,380, adjust after review. 22.Duane & Kay Bush-#204 Plaza Place Condos Lt 12 & N 30’ Lt 13 Auto Plaza Addn from 114,140 to 103,540, adjust after review. 23.Todd Campbell-Lt 2 Elmwood Acres 2nd Addn from 312,690 to 265,360, adjust after review. 24.Kim O Clausen-Lt 20 Blk 21 Simmons 1st Addn from 122,500 to 99,590, adjust after review. 25.Rickter & Betty Clay-Lt 2 Blk 2 Mehlhoffs 6th Addn (Blk 2 North Plains 1st ) from 368,985 to 343,015, adjust after review. 26.Jonathan & Amber Davidson-Lt 3 Sauerwein 1st Subd from 210,230 to 174,400, adjust after review. 27.Delores E Diedtrich-S 60’ Lt 6 Blk 53 2nd Addn from 73,140 to 55,000, adjust after review. 28.Edward & Kay Dosch-Lt 4 Blk 14 8th Addn to Highland North from 177,385 to 153,955, adjust after review. 29.Doug Dryer-Lt 10 Blk 42 2nd Addn from 67,850 to 8,750, adjust after review. 30.Elvin & Delpha Dumdei-#301 S 120’ Lt 13 & N 60’ Lt 14 Auto Plaza Addn from 114,140 to 103,540, adjust after review. 31.Evan Erdmann-Lt 8 & N 4’ Lt 9 Blk 22 Simmons 1st Addn from 118,730 to 107,510, adjust after review. 32.Elroy & Vivian Eske-#103 Plaza Place Condos Lt 12 & N 30’ Lt 13 Auto Plaza Addn from 114,140 to 103,540, adjust after review. 33.Alex Falk-Lt 8-13 Blk 28 Corrected Plat of Highlands & Lt 2 Maloney 1st Addn from 551,835 to 475,390, adjust after review. 34.Justin Feickert-Lt 1 Blk 1 D & G 3rd Subd Roosevelt Crystal Subd from 289,090 to 242,510, adjust after review. 35.Marian L Finwall-Lt 23 Blk 6 Mel Ros 1st Addn to Mel Ros Estates Addn from 118,466 to 114,336, adjust after review. 36.August & Alegra Fischer-#306 S 120’ Lt 13 & N 60’ Lt 14 Auto Plaza Addn from 114,140 to 103,540, adjust after review. 37.Helen Fry -#305 S 120’ Lt 13 & N 60’ Lt 14 Auto Plaza Addn from 114,140 to 103,540, adjust after review. 38.Brian Frost & Diane Cummings-#515 Lt 2 Rolling Hills Village 5th Addn from 288,380 to 261,960, adjust after review. 39.Elsie Geffre-Lt 2 Huffmans 4th Addn from 111,953 to 103,218, adjust after review. 40.Jay R Gellhaus-Lt 19 Blk 7 17th Addn to Highland North from 393,325 to 331,725, adjust after review. 41.Patrick & Mona Gillick-W 96.22’ L 745-746 & W 96.22’ of N 8’ Lt 744 Morning Heights Addn from 68,890 to 60,120, adjust after review. 42.Daniel Grewe-W 80’ Lt 4 Blk 11 11th Addn to Highland North from 234,090 to 186,420, adjust after review. 43.Mark Gederos-Lt 10 Blk 8 15th Addn to Highland North from 162,380 to 153,740, adjust after review. 44-75.Richard Halstead-Lts 1-12 Blk 1 Halsteads 1st Subd from 5,000 to 1,610; Lt 1 Blk 2 Halstads 1st Subd from 5,000 to 2,420; Lt 2 Blk 2 Halstads 1st Subd from 5,000 to 2,570; Lt 3, Blk 2 Halstads 1st Subd from 5,000 to 1,610; Lt 4 Blk 2 Halstads 1st Subd from 5,000 to 2,430; Lts 1-11 Blk 3 Halsteads 1st Subd from 5,000 to 1,610; Lt 12 Blk 3 Halsteads 1st Subd from 5,000 to 2,100; Lt 1 Blk 4 Halsteads 1st Subd from 5,000 to 2,170; Lt 2 Blk 4 Halsteads 1st Subd from 5,000 to 2,240; Lt 3 Blk 4 Halsteads 1st Subd from 5,000 to 2,180; Blk 5 Halsteads 1st Subd from 10,000 to 27,910, adjust after review. 76.Earl & Nina Haugen-E 75’ Lt 25 Blk 8 Melros 4th Addn to Melros Estates from 208,468 to 206,483, adjust after review. 77.Kay Hohnecker-#104 Plaza Place Condos Lt 12 & N 30’ Lt 13 Auto Plaza Addn from 114,140 to 103,540, adjust after review. 78.Leslie & Jennifer Huettl-Lt 2 Blk 3 Roosevelt Estates from 448,745 to 342,475, adjust after review. 79.Jason & Angela Jackson-Lt 7 Blk 49 Bennett & Thomas Addn from 65,415 to 56,180, adjust after review. 80.Fred A Johnson-Lt 10 & W ½ Lt 11 Blk 12 West Hill Addn from 52,735 to 32,695, adjust after review. 81.James Kaiser-Lt 26 Blk 15 13th Addn to Highland North from 159,595 to 153,885, adjust after review. 82.Helen Kolden-#102 Plaza Place Condos Lt 12 & N 30’ Lt 13 Auto Plaza Addn from 114,140 to 103,540, adjust after review. 83.Helen Kopecky-Lt 12 & N 30’ Lt 13 #101 Plat of Auto Plaza Addn from 114,140 to 103,540, adjust after review. 84.Jeff Lamont-Lt 5 Blk 1 Willowwood Addn @ 262,610, maintain equalization. 85.Lamont Enterprises-N ½ NE 20-123-63 ex land platted inc land in S ½ NE in city limits @ 413,340, maintain equalization. 86.Lamont Development LLC-NE NW 20-123-63 ex W ½ W ½ W ½ @ 356,176, maintain equalization. 87.James & Betty Lemler-#202 Plaza Place Condos Lt 12 & N 30’ Lt 13 Auto Plaza Addn from 114,140 to 103,540, adjust after review. 88.Catherine K Lindemann-Lt 11 Blk 7 Melros 1st Addn to Melros Estates from 160,237 to 152,747, adjust after reveiw. 89.Jerry Maier-Lt 25 Blk 9 11th Addn to Highland North from 176,030 to 155,090, adjust after review. 90.Donna M Markley-Lt 4 Clocksins Replat Lts 11-12 Blk 46 2nd Addn and portion of vacated alley from 77,273 to 71,473, adjust after review. 91.Max & Marjorie Marquardt-#303 S 120’ Lt 13 & N 60’ Lt 14 Auto Plaza Addn from 114,140 to 103,540, adjust after review. 92.Clifford & Leona Martz-#203 Plaza Place Condos Lt 12 & N 30’ Lt 13 Auto Plaza Addn from 114,140 to 103,540, adjust after review. 93.Robert & Donna Masters-#206 Plaza Place Condos Lt 12 & N 30’ Lt 13 Auto Plaza Addn from 114,140 to 103,540, adjust after review. 94.Alma McKelvey Trust-#106 Plaza Condos Lt 12 & N 30’ Lt 13 Auto Plaza Addn from 114,140 to 103,540, adjust after review. 95.Peter & Patricia Mehlhaff-Lts 10-11 Campbells Subd Replat of Plat G of Lt 2 Elmwood Acres in NW 12-123-64 from 436,120 to 381,500, adjust after review. 96.Wayne Miller-Lt 3 Miller Subd Lt 1 McIntyres Subd SW 16-123-63 from 162,905 to 104,495, adjust after review. 97.Charlie & Lucille Mitchell-#203 S 120’ Lt 13 & N 60’ Lt 14 Auto Plaza Addn from 114,140 to 103,540, adjust after review. 98.Helen Moulton-#105 Plaza Place Condos Lt 12 & N 30’ Lt 13 Auto Plaza Addn from 114,140 to 103,540, adjust after review. 99.Ronnie & Jean Nold-Lt 3 Blk 1 1st Addn to Highland North from 267,960 to 247,765, adjust after review. 100.Dorothy O’Keefe-#202 S 120’ Lt 13 & N 60’ Lt 14 Auto Plaza Addn from 114,140 to 103,540, adjust after review. 101.Olga Olson-#304 S 120’ Lt 13 & N 60’ Lt 14 Auto Plaza Addn from 114,140 to 103,540, adjust after review. 102.Esther M Patterson-S 25’ Lts 13 & 14 Blk 24 Simmons 1st Addn from 123,030 to 109,350, adjust after review. 103.Walter V Plumage-Lt 6 Blk 2 Huffmans 3rd Addn from 149,612 to 127,412, adjust after review. 104.Judith Porter-#204 S 120’ Lt 13 & N 60’ Lt 14 Auto Plaza Addn from 114,140 to 103,540, adjust after review. 105.Primrose Cottages-Lt 1 Primrose Cottages from 944,198 to 708,788, adjust after review. 106.Property Management & Construction-E 40’ of N 15’ Lt 13 & E 40’ Lt 14 Blk 37 Thomas Addn from 31,155 to 29,000, adjust after review. 107.Duane & Isabel Riedel-Lt 3 & S 5’ Lt 2 Blk 4 Gorders Replat 4th Addn from 225,046 to 193,940, adjust after review. 108-111.Rolling Hills Golf Club LLC-Lt 2 Rolling Hills Village 6th Addn from 24,530 to 38,165; Lt C Rolling Hills Village 10th Addn from 444,688 to 246,960; Lt B Rolling Hills Village 10th Addn from 23,690 to 3,500, adjust after review; Lt 10 Rolling Hills Village 6th Addn @ 90,365, maintain equalization. 112-113.Rubloff Tri-State Lakewood Portfolio LLC-Lt 2A of Dial Third Addn SE 17-123-63 from 13,565,275 to 10,731,592; Lt 2B of Dial Third Addn SE 17-123-63 from 227,380 to 181,906, adjust after review. 114.Patrick Russell-E 99.58’ of Lt 2 Blk 5 North Plains from 186,810 to 180,000, adjust after review. 115.Mary Lu Sanderson-#205 S 120’ Lt 13 & N 60’ Lt 14 Auto Plaza Addn from 114,140 to 103,540, adjust after review. 116.Karen Sandquist-Fleming-Lt 12 Blk 6 Forest Acres 3rd Addn from 111,510 to 103,860, adjust after review. 117.Corey Sauerwein-Lt 6 Sauerwein 1st Subd (pt Lockington OL 1) from 280,190 to 226,430, adjust after review. 118.Ray Sauerwein-W 35’ Lts 7-8 Blk 50 Bennett & Thomas Addn from 37,455 to 6,880, adjust after review. 119.Frank Scepaniak-S ½ Lts 13-14 Blk 15 Thomas Addn from 160,221 to 143,659, adjust after review. 120.Julius D. Schipke-Lt 2 Hermans Replat of Blk 7 Pleasant Hill Addn from 53,332 to 46,612, adjust after review. 121.Carl Schoch-#201 Plaza Place Condos Lt 12 & N 30’ Lt 13 Auto Plaza Addn from 114,140 to 103,540, adjust after review. 122.Warren & Ruth Schumacher-#205 Plaza Place Condos Lt 12 & N 30’ Lt 13 Auto Plaza Addn from 114,140 to 103,540, adjust after review. 123.Eric Barnett-Lt 11 Blk 29 1st Addn to Highlands from 74,650 to 59,510, adjust after review. 124.Anthony & Barbara Schwan-Lt 6 Boulevards Subd SE 6-123-63 from 498,550 to 469,120, adjust after review. 125.Ron Snaza-Lt A Snazas 1st Subd NE 20-123-63 from 72,330 to 70,410, adjust after review. 126.Squash-Lts 17-18 Blk 6 OP from 133,120 to 129,036, adjust after review. 127.Scott Stolle-Lt 5 Blk 1 Mehlhoffs 11th Addn from 245,165 to 189,220, adjust after review. 128.Vincent V Stolz-Lt 13 & N ½ Lt 14 Lawsons 1st Replat Blk 10 Woolverton Addn from 172,385 to 128,860, adjust after review. 129.Joyce Stugelmayer-Lt 8 Lawsons 1st Replat Blk 10 Woolvertons Addn from 84,240 to 82,600, adjust after review. 130.William Svenson-Lt 3 NE 20-123-63 ex Lt A Snaza 1st Subd & Hwy from 289,725 to 220,555, adjust after review. 131.Dwight B Syverson-Lt 2 Tarrell-Syverson Subd (Lts 937-942 Morning Heights) from 77,075 to 62,275, adjust after review. 132.Alice Taylor-#302 S 120’ Lt 13 & N 60’ Lt 14 Auto Plaza Addn from 109,700 to 103,540, adjust after review. 133.Leslie K Tebben-Lt 3 Elmwood Acres 2nd Addn from 308,980 to 254,785, adjust after review. 134.James Thorpe-Lt 10 Blk 19 Ganje Addn to Melros Estates from 98,526 to 86,500, adjust after review. 135.Bernard Tomek-Lt 1 Tomek 1st Subd from 151,110 to 111,250, adjust after review. 136.Kristen Truman-N 24’ Lt 10 Blk 46 Hagerty & Lloyds Addn from 39,190 to 26,890, adjust after review. 137.Patricia Tunheim-#206 S 120’ Lt 13 & N 60’ Lt 14 Auto Plaza Addn, from 114,140 to 103,540, adjust after review. 138.Joseph VanDeRostyne-Lt 8 Eastons 1st Subd Blk 35 Bennett & Thomas Addn from 44,900 to 34,470, adjust after review. 139.Bonnie VanDeRostyne-Lt 4 Blk 22 Thomas Addn from 111,025 to 94,130, adjust after review. 140.Paul & Katherine Vetch-Lt 16 Blk 8 Melros 4th Addn from 131,027 to 126,299, adjust after review. 141.Wagner Holding LLC-Lt 13 & E 16.5’ Lt 14 Blk 8 Nicolet Park Addn from 104,555 to 85,328, adjust after review. 142.John Weaver-Lt 23-27 Blk 28 Corrected Plat of the Highlands & Lt 5 Maloneys 1st from 365,805 to 316,210, adjust after review. 143.Gene & Mary Lou Welk-#201 S 120’ Lt 13 & N 60’ Lt 14 Auto Plaza Addn from 114,140 to 103,540, adjust after review. 144.Lawrence Welk-Lt 18-20 Blk 93 Hagerty & Lloyd Addn from 131,975 to 104,470, adjust after review. 145.Allan Wellman-Lt 1 Voights Subd Blk 74 Hagerty & Lloyds Addn from 70,460 to 57,680, adjust after review. 146.Rodney Wertman-Lt 7 Sauerwein 1st Subd (pt Lockington OL 1) from 222,680 to 184,710, adjust after review. 147.Brenda & Randy White-W 75’ Lt 24 Blk 8 Melros 4th Addn to Melros Estates from 231,948 to 215,678, adjust after review. 148.Lee Wilson-Lt 24 Blk 7 19th Addn to Highland North from 373,675 to 310,035, adjust after review. 149.Robert & Kathy Zerr-Lt 3 Blk 3 College Subd Blk 8-11 Simmons 1st Addn from 168,590 to 159,860, adjust after review. All members present voting aye. Motion carried.

Moved by Sutton, seconded by Elliott to approve the following recommendation from the Director of Equalization: 150.3M Center Building-NW ¼ Sec 16-T123N-R63W of the 5th P.M., Brown County, SD @ 14,755,585, maintain equalization. All members present voting aye. Motion carried.

Moved by Elliott, seconded by Alm to approve the following recommendation from the Director of Equalization: 151-161.Blackstone Developers-Lt 1-2 & N 20.9’ & W 42’ of S 41’ Lt 3 & W 42’ N 19’ Lt 4 Blk 10 OP from 1,221,317 to 1,097,715; Alonzo Wards Condo Commons Area Lt 1-2 & N 20.9’ & W 42’ of S 41’ Lt 3 & W 42’ N 19’ Lt 4 Blk 10 OP from 336,227 to 268,980; N 120’ Lt 1 Blackstone 4th Subd from 1,631,912 to 1,312,350; Balance of Lt 1 Blackstone 4th Subd from 403,566 to 324,578, adjust after review. Unit 3M Alonzo Ward Plaza Residential Suites @ 182,402; Unit 3N Alonzo Ward Plaza Residential Suites @ 237,739; Unit 3P Alonzo Ward Plaza Residential Suites @ 300,402; Unit 4R Alonzo Ward Plaza Residential Suites @ 237,914; Unit 5T Alonzo Ward Plaza Residential Suites @ 187,459; Unit 5U Alonzo Ward Plaza Residential Suites @ 237,914; Unit 6A Alonzo Ward Plaza Residential Suites @ 407,098, maintain equalization. All members present voting aye. Motion carried.

Moved by Alm, seconded by Levsen to approve the following recommendation from the Director of Equalization: 162.Culvers-Lt 3 1st Replat Lamont 1st Addn NE 20-123-63 @ 906,295, maintain equalization. 163.Shopko Properties-Shopko OL of Howards OL B NE 14-123-64 from 2,386,530 to 1,992,227, adjust after review. 164.Evergreen Supply-S 267’ OL D Lincoln & Boyds Subd from 304,967 to 281,288, adjust after review. All members present voting aye. Motion carried.

ADJOURNMENT:
Moved by Sutton, seconded by Levsen to adjourn the 2009 Consolidated Board of Equalization. All members present voting aye. Motion carried.

Maxine Taylor – Brown County Auditor